The question comes first
Give small groups a question with more than one defensible answer. In geography, they might choose the best location for a new community garden using a map, shade observations and access needs. A shared document gives each group one place to gather evidence and revise a recommendation. The aim is to make their reasoning visible.
Set up the workspace
Create a template with five headings: question, evidence, options, decision and reflection. Give edit access only to the group. Put the instructions in the classroom as well as online. A naming rule such as “Group 3, Garden Site” prevents confusion. Ask pupils to avoid entering personal details about themselves or neighbours.
Make participation visible
Assign roles for the first round, then switch them. The researcher records sources; the challenger asks what evidence is missing; the editor writes the current recommendation. Leave two minutes for every pupil to add a comment or question. The teacher can then see who needs support without using edit counts as a measure of learning.
Close the lesson and assess it
Each group presents one claim and one uncertainty. Peers respond with a specific question. Assess the quality of evidence, the response to feedback and each learner’s short reflection. If the network fails, use the printed template and take a photo of the final sheet only if your school’s rules permit it. After class, duplicate a clean template rather than sharing the previous group’s work.
